Managing AI-Related Business Disputes

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including commercial disputes. AI-related disputes generally concern the use, supply, ownership or governance of artificial intelligence systems within a business relationship.

Common sources of dispute

Disputes can arise from inaccurate or harmful AI-generated outputs, failures to meet contractual specifications, unauthorised use of confidential information, data protection breaches, intellectual property complaints and disagreements about responsibility for human decisions supported by AI. A contract may address service levels, permitted data, security, audit rights, liability limits, intellectual property ownership and termination. Where these terms are unclear, the parties may disagree about whether the problem is a breach of contract, negligence, misuse of information or an intellectual property infringement.

Initial response

A business should preserve relevant evidence, including prompts, outputs, model settings, system logs, policies, training materials, contracts and communications. It should identify who supplied the system, who authorised its use, what information was processed and what loss or harm resulted. The business should also consider whether continued use of the system creates an ongoing risk. A factual chronology and clear separation between verified events and assumptions assist with assessing the dispute.

Resolution and prevention

The parties can then review the contract, quantify the alleged loss and decide whether correspondence, negotiation or mediation is appropriate. Court proceedings may be required where urgent relief, disclosure or a binding decision is necessary. Future agreements can reduce uncertainty by allocating responsibility for data, outputs, monitoring, regulatory compliance, indemnities and limitations of liability. Internal approval procedures, staff guidance and records of human review also provide evidence of how the system was used, although they do not remove contractual or legal responsibility.