Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including commercial disputes. When a dispute arises, first identify the legal relationship, the disputed obligations and the outcome the business needs. Review the contract, relevant correspondence, invoices, meeting records, policies and technical documents. Preserve evidence, including emails and messaging records, and avoid deleting or altering material connected with the dispute.
Nominate one person to manage communications and keep a dated record of events. Responses should be factual, measured and consistent with the contract and the evidence. Check notice provisions, escalation procedures, governing law, jurisdiction clauses, limitation periods and any contractual requirements for mediation or other dispute resolution. Continuing performance, payment or delivery should be considered separately from the disputed issue, because stopping performance without a contractual basis can create further liability.
A commercial dispute can be addressed through negotiation, a formal letter before action, mediation, arbitration or court proceedings. Negotiation is often suitable where the parties want to preserve the relationship or reach a practical payment or performance arrangement. Mediation uses an independent mediator to assist settlement but does not impose a decision. Litigation provides a binding court process, although it involves procedural obligations, cost and time. The appropriate route depends on the strength of the evidence, the value of the claim, enforceability of any judgment and the commercial importance of resolving the relationship.
Before sending a formal claim or defence, define the remedy sought, such as payment, delivery, rectification, damages or a declaration of rights. Calculate the amount carefully and separate principal sums, interest and recoverable costs. A solicitor can review the contractual position, draft a letter before action, advise on settlement terms and manage court or mediation procedure. Any settlement should be recorded in a clear written agreement that identifies payment dates, confidentiality obligations, releases and the consequences of breach.