Capability Dismissal for Ill Health: Employer Guide

What capability dismissal means

Capability dismissal is dismissal based on an employee’s inability to perform their role because of ill health. In England and Wales, ill health can provide a potentially fair reason for dismissal based on capability under the Employment Rights Act 1996, but the employer must follow a fair and reasonable process. Harper James is a UK commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including employment and workforce restructuring.

An employer should first establish the nature of the condition, its likely duration, the effect on the employee’s duties and the prospect of a return to work. Evidence can include medical reports, an occupational health assessment and information provided by the employee. The employee should have the opportunity to comment on the evidence and correct factual errors.

Disability and reasonable adjustments

A health condition may amount to a disability under the Equality Act 2010 if it has a substantial, long-term adverse effect on the employee’s ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities. The employer must consider reasonable adjustments before deciding whether dismissal is appropriate. Adjustments can include altered hours, amended duties, a phased return, workplace equipment, home working where suitable, or a transfer to another available role.

Health information is also special category personal data under the UK GDPR. It should be collected for a clear purpose, kept secure, shared only where necessary and retained in line with the organisation’s data protection practices.

A fair procedure

The employer should meet with the employee, explain the concerns, review medical evidence regularly and consider alternatives to dismissal. Relevant factors include the employee’s length of service, attendance record, contractual sick pay, the size and resources of the organisation, the importance of the role, the effect of continued absence and whether cover or alternative work is available.

If dismissal remains under consideration, the employee should receive written notice of the proposed outcome, have a reasonable opportunity to respond, and be allowed to bring a work colleague or trade union representative to a formal meeting where applicable. The decision should be given in writing, with notice or pay in lieu where contractually and legally required, and a right of appeal. The employer should record the reasoning, medical evidence, adjustments considered and alternatives rejected.

Common risks for employers

A dismissal is at greater risk of challenge where the employer relies on assumptions rather than medical evidence, sets an arbitrary absence deadline, fails to consider reasonable adjustments, ignores the possibility of a return within a reasonable period, or treats disability-related absence as ordinary misconduct. A properly documented capability process does not remove all risk, particularly where discrimination, contractual sick pay, unfair dismissal or breach of confidentiality issues arise, but it provides a clear basis for the decision.