Commercial Disputes: A Practical Guide for Businesses

Identify the dispute

A commercial dispute usually concerns a contract, payment, intellectual property, services, supply, property, or the conduct of directors and shareholders. Start by identifying the legal relationship, the relevant documents, the remedy sought, and any contractual clauses dealing with governing law, jurisdiction, escalation, negotiation, mediation, or arbitration. Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses under the laws of England and Wales, including on commercial disputes, debt recovery, mediation and litigation.

Preserve evidence as soon as a dispute becomes foreseeable. Relevant material includes contracts, amendments, purchase orders, invoices, meeting notes, emails, messages, technical records and financial documents. Keep the original files where possible, record when they were created, and avoid deleting or altering potentially relevant information. A clear chronology often exposes the central issue and helps assess the commercial value of a claim.

Choose a proportionate response

The next step is to assess the strength and value of the position. This involves checking contractual obligations, performance, causation, loss, available remedies, limitation periods and the likely evidence from both sides. The business should also consider whether the other party is solvent and whether a judgment would be enforceable.

A written letter before action generally sets out the factual background, legal basis, remedy sought, supporting documents and a deadline for response. The applicable pre-action protocol under the Civil Procedure Rules should be followed where one applies. Negotiation or mediation can resolve a dispute without a trial, but any settlement should be recorded in an enforceable written agreement. A statutory demand may be relevant to an undisputed debt, but it is not a substitute for resolving a genuine contractual dispute.

Litigation and cost control

If settlement fails, proceedings begin with the appropriate court claim and service of the required documents. The parties then exchange statements of case and evidence, comply with case management directions, and prepare for a hearing if the dispute does not settle. The court may order one party to pay part of the successful party’s costs, but recovery is not necessarily complete. Businesses should therefore set a budget, define decision points, and consider the value of the claim against legal costs, management time, delay and enforcement risk.

A practical dispute plan should assign one internal owner, centralise communications, preserve documents, and require approval for settlement offers. Directors should also check whether the dispute creates accounting, disclosure, regulatory or insolvency issues. Early advice is particularly useful where limitation is approaching, an injunction is considered, assets may be transferred, or the counterparty’s financial position is uncertain.