Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising start-ups, scale-ups and established businesses on the laws of England and Wales. Competition clauses in commercial contracts can protect commercial relationships, confidential information and investment, but an overbroad restriction can be difficult to enforce and can create competition law risk.
A competition clause can restrict a supplier, distributor, shareholder, franchisee or joint venture partner from competing with the business. Common provisions include non-compete obligations, non-solicitation clauses, customer and employee restrictions, exclusivity commitments, territorial limits and controls on using confidential information.
The first question is whether the restriction protects a legitimate business interest, such as customer connections, trade secrets, a carefully developed market or a joint venture investment. The drafting then needs a defensible limit on duration, territory, activities and the people or customers covered. A clause preventing a former distributor from serving every customer in an entire industry is harder to justify than one limited to named accounts and a defined product line. Further guidance on commercial contract drafting provides useful context for reviewing these provisions alongside the rest of the agreement.
Contractual restrictions also need to comply with UK competition law. Exclusivity, resale restrictions and non-compete terms attract particular attention where a party has significant market power or the agreement affects an important route to market. The UK Vertical Agreements Block Exemption Order provides a framework for some supplier and distributor arrangements, but protection depends on the structure and effect of the agreement. An obligation with an indefinite term or automatic renewal is generally outside the block exemption for non-compete purposes.
Recent practice places greater weight on evidence. Businesses should record the commercial reason for the restriction, identify the market affected and check whether a narrower clause protects the same interest. A restriction linked to a defined transition period, customer list or territory is easier to assess than a general prohibition on competition. Employment non-compete reforms have also increased scrutiny of restraint clauses, although proposals or rules applying to employment contracts do not automatically change business-to-business agreements.
Before signing, map the parties’ roles and identify the specific risk the clause addresses. Check the duration, territory, restricted activities, carve-outs and interaction with confidentiality, intellectual property and termination provisions. Consider whether exclusivity is reciprocal, whether performance targets apply and what happens if the protected party fails to meet its commitments. Avoid relying on a court removing excessive wording later, as severance is limited and the remaining clause may not produce the intended protection.
For a new agreement, negotiate the restriction with the commercial model in view. For an existing agreement, review it before a renewal, acquisition, new distribution channel or change in market position. The wording should reflect the transaction, the legitimate interest being protected and the relevant competition law considerations, rather than treating every restriction as a standard template term.