Competition Law Compliance for Commercial Agreements

Harper James advises UK businesses on commercial agreements under the laws of England and Wales, including competition law requirements. Compliance should be considered when drafting, negotiating, renewing, and enforcing contracts, particularly where an agreement affects pricing, distribution, market access, or dealings with competitors.

Main competition law risks

The Competition Act 1998 prohibits agreements, decisions, and concerted practices that prevent, restrict, or distort competition. This includes arrangements between competitors to fix prices, divide markets or customers, limit production, rig tenders, or exchange commercially sensitive information. Restrictions between suppliers and distributors also require review. Resale price maintenance, certain territorial restrictions, and wide most-favoured-customer clauses require particular care. Some vertical arrangements fall within the Vertical Agreements Block Exemption Order 2022, but the exemption depends on specific conditions, including market share thresholds and the nature of the restriction.

Businesses with a dominant position have additional responsibilities under the Chapter II prohibition. Contract terms involving exclusivity, loyalty rebates, tying, discriminatory treatment, or refusal to supply require assessment where they may exclude competitors or exploit customers. An agreement does not avoid scrutiny simply because it is commercially common, recorded in standard terms, or approved by senior management.

A practical review process

A compliance review should begin by identifying the parties, their market positions, the relevant products or services, and the commercial purpose of each restriction. The review should then examine pricing provisions, exclusivity, non-compete obligations, customer and territory allocation, distribution controls, information-sharing clauses, termination rights, and restrictions on selling through online channels. The agreement should state the intended scope clearly and avoid wording that extends beyond the legitimate commercial objective.

Internal controls are also necessary. Sales and procurement teams should know which subjects cannot be discussed with competitors, including future prices, margins, output, customers, tenders, and business strategy. Businesses should retain a clear record of the legal and commercial rationale for restrictions, apply an approval process for higher-risk clauses, and review agreements when market conditions or the parties' market shares change.

Consequences of non-compliance

The Competition and Markets Authority can investigate suspected infringements and impose fines of up to 10% of an undertaking's worldwide turnover. Infringing provisions can be unenforceable, and affected customers or competitors can bring damages claims. Directors and employees can also face personal consequences in certain circumstances, including director disqualification or criminal liability for cartel conduct. A contract that appears operationally effective can therefore create substantial legal and commercial exposure if its restrictions have not been assessed.