Competition Law in Franchise Agreements

Why competition law matters

A franchise agreement controls branding, operating methods, supply arrangements and territory, but it must also comply with UK competition law. Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including franchising and commercial contracts. The Competition Act 1998 applies to arrangements that restrict competition, and franchisors should assess the commercial effect of each restriction rather than relying on a standard template.

The main restrictions to review

The Vertical Agreements Block Exemption Order 2022, known as VABEO, provides a framework for assessing many vertical agreements between businesses at different levels of the supply chain. A franchisor and franchisee will often fall within this category. The block exemption generally depends on each party having no more than a 30% market share and the agreement avoiding serious restrictions, known as hardcore restrictions. These include fixing the minimum or fixed price at which a franchisee resells goods or services. Recommended prices and maximum prices require careful drafting so that they do not operate as indirect minimum resale price maintenance. For further detail, see this competition law resource.

Territory, online sales and non-compete clauses

Territorial and customer restrictions need particular attention. A franchise network can allocate territories and protect certain customer groups, but clauses that prevent legitimate passive sales or unduly restrict online selling create competition law risk. Online sales bans are especially difficult to justify where they remove an effective channel for reaching customers. Non-compete clauses also require review. Restrictions lasting more than five years, or beyond the agreement’s term, will not generally benefit from the block exemption, subject to limited exceptions and the specific facts. Confidentiality and brand-protection provisions should be drafted narrowly around genuine know-how and legitimate commercial interests.

A practical drafting process

Before signing or renewing an agreement, map the relevant products, services, territories and sales channels, then estimate the parties’ market shares using a sensible and documented methodology. Identify every restriction affecting price, territory, customers, online sales, purchasing and post-termination activity. Separate brand standards and legitimate quality controls from provisions that dictate commercial conduct. Finally, record the rationale for each restriction and establish a review point when the network, market or agreement changes. A competition law review at the drafting stage is usually more effective than trying to amend a network-wide franchise model after disputes arise.