Harper James advises UK employers on workforce restructuring under the laws of England and Wales, including redundancy consultation, selection processes and settlement agreements. A well-run process protects the business while treating affected employees fairly and maintaining trust across the organisation.
Start by recording the genuine business reason, the proposed number of roles affected, the relevant establishment and the available alternatives, such as recruitment freezes, reduced overtime, redeployment or voluntary redundancy. If an employer proposes 20 or more redundancies at one establishment within a 90-day period, collective consultation rules apply. The minimum consultation period is 30 days before the first dismissal where 20 to 99 redundancies are proposed, and 45 days where 100 or more are proposed. Employers must consult recognised trade union representatives or elected employee representatives and notify the Secretary of State using form HR1. Practical guidance on the process provides a useful starting point for building an internal timetable and document checklist.
Collective consultation does not replace individual consultation. Each affected employee should receive clear information about the proposal, the reasons for it, the proposed selection pool and criteria, and the alternatives considered. Meetings should be genuine discussions, not announcements of a predetermined decision. Give employees reasonable time to respond, consider their suggestions, and keep accurate notes. Selection criteria need to be objective and consistently applied. Attendance, performance, skills, qualifications, disciplinary records and length of service require careful handling, while absence connected with disability, pregnancy or family leave presents particular discrimination risks.
Keep a written audit trail covering the business case, consultation invitations, meeting notes, scoring records, equality checks, alternative roles and the reasons for accepting or rejecting suggestions. Check suitable alternative vacancies before issuing dismissal notices, including any statutory trial period where appropriate. Calculate notice pay, accrued holiday, redundancy pay and any contractual benefits accurately. Employees with two years’ service generally qualify for statutory redundancy pay, subject to the statutory calculation rules. A settlement agreement has a separate purpose and requires independent advice for the employee, so it should not replace a fair consultation process.
Remote and hybrid working have made consultation meetings easier to arrange, but employers still need to provide accessible information, allow proper representation and protect confidential employee data. Boards and HR teams are also placing greater emphasis on scenario planning, consistent selection scoring and early equality impact reviews. Harper James can advise on the business case, collective and individual consultation, selection documentation, TUPE-related restructuring, settlement agreements and the final dismissal steps, with the scope and charging basis agreed at the outset.