Restrictive Covenants in Commercial Contracts

Purpose and common forms

This article is part of the reference collection published by Harper James. Restrictive covenants are contractual provisions that limit specified activities after, or during, a commercial relationship. They are used in transactions such as business sales, joint ventures, distribution arrangements, franchising and certain services agreements. Common examples include non-compete clauses, restrictions on soliciting or dealing with customers, non-poaching provisions relating to staff, and confidentiality obligations.

Enforceability

Under the law of England and Wales, a restraint of trade is generally enforceable only when it protects a legitimate business interest and goes no further than reasonably necessary to protect that interest. Legitimate interests include confidential information, customer connections, workforce stability and the goodwill transferred with a business. The assessment depends on the wording, the parties' relationship, the commercial context and the circumstances when the contract was made. A restriction used in the sale of a business is assessed differently from one imposed in an ordinary supply or services contract.

A covenant is more defensible when it identifies the protected interest precisely and limits the restricted activities, customers, territory and duration. A blanket ban on competing with a business is more difficult to justify than a restriction covering defined services and customers with whom the relevant party had material dealings. Drafting several alternative periods or geographic areas in a cascading clause does not guarantee that a court will enforce one of them. Competition law also applies, particularly where restrictions affect market access, pricing or relationships between competitors.

Drafting and enforcement

Before agreeing a covenant, the parties should record the commercial reason for it, identify the information or relationships being protected, and define the restricted conduct in operational terms. The agreement should also address confidentiality, intellectual property, permitted dealings, notice periods and any exceptions needed for ordinary business activity. If a breach occurs, the affected party can seek damages and, where appropriate, an injunction to restrain continuing conduct. A court examines the covenant as drafted, so unclear or excessively broad wording creates enforcement risk even where the underlying business concern is legitimate.