Harper James advises businesses under the laws of England and Wales on protecting copyright, establishing ownership and responding to suspected infringement. Copyright evidence must address two separate questions: who owns the work and whether another party has copied a protected part of it.
Copyright generally arises automatically when an original literary, artistic, musical, dramatic or software work is created. Evidence of ownership includes source files, drafts, development records, design files, version histories, publication records and dated correspondence. Metadata and digital timestamps support a claim, but they do not by themselves establish authorship or ownership. A clear chain of title is also important. Written assignments should identify the work and be signed by the assignor. Employment contracts, contractor agreements and commissioning terms should state who owns newly created material, since ownership rules differ between employees and independent contractors.
Infringement evidence usually compares the original work with the allegedly infringing version. Useful material includes archived web pages, screenshots, URLs, download records, product samples, source code comparisons and records showing when the material was first identified. The claimant generally needs to show access to the original work and copying of a substantial part of its protected expression. Similarity alone does not prove infringement where the similarities arise from common ideas, standard features or independently created material. Copyright protects the expression of an idea, not the idea itself.
Businesses should preserve original files in their existing form, record the date and method of collection, and keep copies of relevant contracts, invoices, emails and publication records. A witness statement can explain how the work was created, stored and published. For online infringement, an independent capture of the relevant page and its underlying files provides stronger evidence than an undated screenshot. A letter before action normally sets out the rights relied upon, the infringing acts, the evidence, and the remedy sought. Available remedies include an injunction, damages or an account of profits, delivery up or destruction of infringing articles, and a declaration of rights. The appropriate response depends on the strength of the evidence, the commercial value of the work and the cost of enforcement.