Harper James advises businesses on commercial disputes under the laws of England and Wales, including the planning and control of litigation spend. A costs budget sets out the expected legal costs of each stage of a claim and provides a framework for monitoring expenditure.
A useful budget separates solicitor and barrister fees, court fees, expert evidence, document management, travel, counsel conferences and other disbursements. It should divide costs by litigation stage, such as pre-action correspondence, pleadings, disclosure, witness evidence, expert evidence, interim applications, trial preparation and the trial itself. The budget should also identify assumptions, including the number of parties, volume of documents, likely witnesses and estimated trial length.
The budget must distinguish between the costs paid by the client and the costs recoverable from an opponent. The court may order the unsuccessful party to pay a proportion of the successful party’s costs, but recovery is not automatic and generally does not cover every expense. A solicitor should therefore present the budget as a cash-flow and risk-management tool, rather than as a forecast of the amount ultimately recovered.
In many multi-track cases, the Civil Procedure Rules require the parties to exchange and file costs budgets, usually using Precedent H, within the relevant timetable. The court may approve, amend or record the budgets at a costs management hearing. Once approved, a party generally requires the court’s permission to depart materially from the budget.
The timing of the budget is important. Missing a filing deadline can lead to serious consequences, including restrictions on the costs that a party can recover. The budget should be updated when the scope of the dispute changes, such as when new evidence emerges, a party adds a claim or defence, or an interim application creates additional work. Changes should be recorded with the reason, estimated cost and effect on later stages.
Businesses should review the budget at regular intervals against invoices, work completed and remaining tasks. A stage-by-stage report can identify whether costs are higher because the work is more complex, the opponent has increased the volume of correspondence, or the original assumptions were incomplete. Alternative dispute resolution, settlement negotiations and a Part 36 offer should be assessed against the projected cost of continuing to trial, as well as the commercial value and evidential strength of the claim.
Before proceedings begin, the board or finance team should approve a written litigation plan. It should state the objectives, authority limits, funding arrangement, settlement strategy, reporting frequency and decision points for continuing or settling. This approach connects the legal budget to the business case and gives decision-makers a clear basis for controlling expenditure as the dispute develops.