Harper James advises businesses on workplace monitoring and data protection under the laws of England and Wales. Workplace monitoring includes reviewing emails, internet use, access logs, location data, CCTV, recorded calls, keystrokes and information generated by security or productivity systems.
Under the UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018, an employer must identify a lawful basis for processing monitoring data, document the purpose and collect only information that is necessary. Legitimate interests is commonly considered in employment settings, but the employer must balance its interests against employees’ privacy rights. Consent is generally unsuitable where there is an imbalance of power between employer and employee.
Monitoring must be proportionate to a defined business purpose. A security system designed to detect unauthorised access requires a different assessment from software that continuously records screenshots or keystrokes. Employers must complete a data protection impact assessment where monitoring is likely to create a high risk to individuals, particularly for systematic or intrusive monitoring.
Employees should receive clear information about what is monitored, why it is monitored, the legal basis, who can access the information, how long it is retained and how they can exercise their data protection rights. Policies should cover personal devices, remote working, communications monitoring, CCTV, use of monitoring software and the handling of information obtained during investigations.
Access should be limited to authorised personnel, with appropriate security controls and retention periods. Employers also need procedures for subject access requests, complaints, data breaches and challenges to inaccurate or unfairly used information. Monitoring data used in disciplinary action should be relevant, reliable and assessed alongside the surrounding facts.
Before introducing a monitoring system, an organisation should define the business problem, consider less intrusive alternatives, consult affected workers where appropriate, complete the required assessment and update its privacy information. It should then configure the system to collect the minimum necessary data, test access controls and review whether the monitoring remains justified. Separate rules may apply to special category data, biometric information, international transfers and electronic marketing or communications, so the proposed system requires a joined-up data protection and employment law assessment.