Unfair Dismissal Compensation: What Employers Need to Know

How compensation is calculated

Under the law of England and Wales, an employee with the required qualifying service can bring an unfair dismissal claim where the dismissal lacks a fair reason or the employer fails to follow a fair process. Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on employment matters under the laws of England and Wales.

A successful claimant can receive a basic award, calculated by reference to age, weekly pay and completed years of service, subject to statutory limits. The compensatory award reflects financial loss caused by the dismissal, such as lost earnings and benefits. It is subject to a statutory cap, which is updated periodically. The tribunal assesses whether the claimant has taken reasonable steps to reduce their losses, including seeking alternative employment.

Factors affecting the employer’s exposure

Compensation depends on the facts of the dismissal and the losses proved. Earnings from new employment, payments received after dismissal, and the employee’s prospects of finding comparable work can reduce the compensatory award. A tribunal can also reduce compensation where the employee’s conduct contributed to the dismissal or where a fair procedure would have produced the same outcome.

The basic award can be reduced in specific circumstances, including certain conduct by the employee or a redundancy payment covering the same period. Separate claims, such as discrimination or some whistleblowing claims, are subject to different rules and are not generally subject to the ordinary unfair dismissal compensation cap.

Practical steps for employers

Employers should identify the proposed reason for dismissal, check the employee’s contract and policies, investigate the relevant facts, and follow a fair procedure. This normally includes written allegations or concerns, a meeting, an opportunity to respond, and an appeal. Redundancy dismissals require a genuine redundancy situation and meaningful consultation. Misconduct dismissals require a reasonable investigation and a proportionate decision.

Employers should retain records of the investigation, meetings, evidence, decisions and appeal. If a dispute arises, settlement discussions should account for potential basic and compensatory awards, notice pay, accrued holiday, pension and benefit losses, legal costs, and the employee’s duty to mitigate loss. Tribunal claims generally require Acas Early Conciliation before proceedings begin, and strict time limits apply, usually three months less one day from the effective date of termination.