Employment Dismissal Checklist

Harper James advises ambitious UK businesses on employment dismissals under the laws of England and Wales, helping directors and HR teams make decisions that are fair, documented and commercially proportionate. A dismissal checklist protects the business by testing both the reason for dismissal and the process used to reach it.

Before deciding to dismiss

Identify the proposed reason: conduct, capability, redundancy, illegality or some other substantial reason. Check the employment contract, staff handbook, disciplinary procedure and any collective agreement. Gather the evidence, including investigation notes, performance records, meeting invitations and relevant emails. Separate fact-finding from the final decision, and check for risks involving discrimination, whistleblowing, trade union activity, family leave, disability or other protected circumstances. The latest employment law guidance provides useful context for reviewing these issues.

Follow a fair process

For conduct or capability cases, investigate properly, give the employee written details of the concerns, hold a meeting, allow reasonable time to prepare and offer the right to be accompanied. Give the employee a genuine opportunity to respond, then issue a clear outcome with reasons and an appeal route. Apply the Acas Code of Practice where it is relevant. An unreasonable failure to follow the Code can result in an employment tribunal increasing certain awards by up to 25%. A redundancy dismissal requires a genuine redundancy situation, a fair pool and selection method, meaningful consultation and consideration of suitable alternative roles.

Final checks and dismissal paperwork

Before issuing the decision, review consistency with comparable cases and confirm that the decision-maker has no conflict of interest. Calculate notice pay, accrued holiday, commission, bonuses and deductions, then check whether garden leave or payment in lieu of notice applies. Provide the dismissal letter, appeal deadline and information about benefits and company property. Record the evidence and decision securely, including any material generated through workplace monitoring or artificial intelligence tools. A settlement agreement is an alternative route where its terms are properly documented and the employee receives independent legal advice, but it should not be used to disguise an unsafe process or unlawful reason for dismissal.