Preserving Evidence in a Commercial Dispute

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including commercial disputes. When a dispute emerges, early control of documents and data can affect the strength, cost and timetable of the case.

Start with a preservation plan

Preservation begins when litigation is reasonably contemplated, not when a claim form arrives. Identify the issues in dispute, the people involved, and the systems they use. This usually includes email, instant messaging, mobile devices, shared drives, customer relationship systems, accounting records, contracts, meeting notes and relevant social media or collaboration platforms. Suspend routine deletion and document the steps taken. A written legal hold should state what must be retained, who is responsible and how compliance will be checked.

Preserve the original evidence

Do not edit, rename, overwrite or selectively export relevant files. Keep original messages and attachments together, retain metadata where it is relevant, and record the source and date of each item. For devices or large data sets, a forensic image or controlled collection by a suitably qualified specialist provides a more reliable record than manual copying. Keep a chain-of-custody log showing who collected, transferred, reviewed or stored the material. Explore further commercial dispute resources for related guidance on disclosure and litigation procedure.

Manage review and disclosure carefully

Create a defensible collection and review process before searching thousands of documents. Use agreed custodians, date ranges, search terms and file types, then test the results for gaps. Separate potentially privileged material from ordinary business records, and avoid treating every communication with a solicitor as privileged. The Civil Procedure Rules require parties to deal with disclosure proportionately and to take reasonable steps to preserve relevant documents. Failure to do so can lead to adverse procedural decisions, costs consequences or restrictions on relying on evidence.

Build the process into business practice

A practical response is to appoint one internal owner, map the relevant data sources, issue written preservation instructions, and arrange periodic checks until the dispute ends. Staff should know that deleting messages, switching to personal accounts or continuing informal discussions about the dispute can create avoidable problems. Record decisions, exceptions and collection results. This creates an evidence trail showing that the organisation acted methodically, while keeping legal spend focused on material that genuinely affects the issues in dispute.