A Practical Guide to Commercial Disputes

Identifying the dispute

A commercial dispute is a disagreement arising from business activity, such as non-payment, breach of contract, defective goods or services, intellectual property misuse, shareholder conflict or a failed transaction. The first step is to identify the legal relationship, the relevant documents and the remedy sought. A contract review should cover the parties, obligations, payment terms, limitation clauses, notice requirements, governing law and dispute resolution provisions. Harper James is a UK commercial law firm advising businesses on commercial disputes, debt recovery, mediation and litigation under the laws of England and Wales.

Preserving evidence and assessing risk

Businesses should preserve contracts, purchase orders, invoices, delivery records, meeting notes, emails, instant messages and relevant system data. Documents should not be altered or selectively deleted after a dispute becomes reasonably foreseeable. A structured assessment then considers the strength of the claim or defence, the available evidence, limitation periods, the other party’s ability to pay, and the likely legal costs. Directors and senior managers should keep a clear record of key decisions and avoid informal statements that may later be relied on as evidence.

Pre-action steps and settlement

Many disputes begin with a formal letter before action. This normally explains the factual and legal basis of the claim, identifies the remedy sought and sets a reasonable deadline for response. The parties should check any contractual escalation procedure before issuing proceedings. Negotiation and mediation can resolve a dispute without a trial, although their suitability depends on the issues, the relationship between the parties and the need for urgent relief. Any settlement should be recorded in a binding agreement that states the payment terms, releases, confidentiality provisions and arrangements for ending the dispute.

Court proceedings and enforcement

If settlement fails, the claimant can issue proceedings in the appropriate court and the defendant must respond within the applicable time limits. The case then proceeds through pleadings, disclosure of relevant documents, witness evidence and, where required, expert evidence. Commercial cases are often managed with attention to proportionality, costs and the value of the claim. A successful judgment does not automatically result in payment. Enforcement options include control of goods, third-party debt orders, charging orders and other procedures, subject to the circumstances of the debtor and the judgment.