A Practical Guide to Mediation and Arbitration in Commercial Disputes

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising start-ups, scale-ups and established companies on the laws of England and Wales, including commercial disputes and mediation. Mediation and arbitration are private dispute-resolution processes that businesses can use instead of, or before, court proceedings.

Mediation

Mediation involves an independent mediator helping the parties explore settlement. The mediator does not usually decide who is right. Discussions are generally conducted on a confidential and “without prejudice” basis, so parties can make settlement proposals without those proposals normally being used as evidence in later proceedings. A settlement becomes legally binding when the parties record the agreed terms, commonly in a settlement agreement.

A practical mediation process starts with checking the dispute-resolution clause, identifying the decision-makers, gathering the key contract documents and preparing a concise position statement. The business should define its commercial objectives, acceptable settlement range, payment terms, confidentiality requirements and any continuing relationship with the other party. Mediation is often suitable where the parties want control over the outcome, need a relatively flexible process or wish to preserve a trading relationship.

Arbitration

Arbitration is a private process in which an arbitrator, or tribunal, determines the dispute and issues an award. The Arbitration Act 1996 provides the main statutory framework for arbitrations seated in England and Wales. The arbitration agreement should be reviewed carefully because it may specify the seat, governing law, institutional rules, number of arbitrators, language and procedure. These terms affect the conduct and cost of the arbitration.

The parties should preserve relevant evidence, identify the contractual and legal issues, and assess the available remedies before commencing arbitration. The tribunal’s award is generally binding, subject to limited grounds for challenge or appeal under the applicable law. Arbitration can provide procedural privacy and a decision from a tribunal with relevant technical or commercial experience, but it still involves tribunal fees, legal costs and procedural management.

Choosing the appropriate process

The choice depends on the contract, the urgency of the dispute, the value and complexity of the claim, the need for a binding decision, the importance of confidentiality and the parties’ willingness to negotiate. Mediation is focused on settlement and party control. Arbitration is focused on obtaining a binding determination. Some disputes use both processes, with mediation attempted before or during arbitration. The contract, evidence, limitation dates and enforcement position should be reviewed before selecting a route.