Start by identifying the contract, obligation or event at the centre of the disagreement. Check the relevant clauses, including payment terms, service levels, warranties, limitation of liability, governing law and dispute resolution procedures. Establish the commercial objective, such as recovering money, preserving a supplier relationship or securing delivery of a project. Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on commercial disputes and the laws of England and Wales.
Create a chronology and preserve relevant evidence. This includes contracts, amendments, purchase orders, invoices, emails, meeting notes, technical records and any notices already sent. Keep communications factual and avoid admissions or allegations that are not supported by the available evidence. Check the limitation period promptly, because a claim can be lost if court proceedings are not started within the applicable time.
Review the contract for requirements to negotiate, mediate or use another dispute resolution process before issuing proceedings. A formal letter before action usually sets out the legal and factual basis of the claim, the remedy sought, the supporting documents and a deadline for response. The letter should be proportionate and consistent with the applicable court rules and pre-action protocol.
Negotiation is often the first practical option because the parties control the outcome and can agree commercial terms that a court cannot order, such as revised delivery arrangements or a continuing supply relationship. Mediation uses an independent mediator to assist settlement discussions. It is confidential, but it does not impose a decision unless the parties record a binding settlement.
If settlement does not resolve the dispute, the claimant can issue court proceedings in the appropriate forum. The process generally involves pleadings, disclosure of relevant documents, witness evidence and, where necessary, expert evidence. The court then determines the issues at a hearing or approves an agreed settlement. Litigation involves court fees, legal costs, management time and procedural deadlines, so the value and enforceability of the claim should be assessed before proceedings begin.
A business can adopt a dispute plan that assigns responsibility for evidence, sets an approval process for settlement offers and records legal spend against the value at stake. Directors and senior managers should receive regular updates on material developments, cash-flow exposure and operational effects. The best route depends on the contract, evidence, limitation position, relationship between the parties and the remedy required.