Unlawful Dividends: Rules for Company Directors

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales. For company directors, the central rule is that a dividend must be paid only from profits legally available for distribution.

When a Dividend Is Lawful

Under the Companies Act 2006, distributable profits are accumulated realised profits less accumulated realised losses. A company must base the decision on relevant accounts, such as annual accounts or properly prepared interim accounts. The accounts must support the amount being distributed at the date of the dividend, not simply show that the company has cash in its bank account.

A final dividend is normally recommended by the directors and declared by the shareholders, usually through an ordinary resolution. Shareholders cannot approve a final dividend above the amount recommended by the board. An interim dividend is generally declared by the directors under the company’s articles. The board should review the latest financial information before each payment and record the decision in minutes.

Directors’ Responsibilities and Consequences

Directors who approve an unlawful dividend can breach their statutory duties and become liable to restore money improperly paid, particularly where the company is insolvent or the payment causes financial harm. A shareholder who receives a dividend knowing, or having reasonable grounds to believe, that it was unlawful is required to repay it under section 847 of the Companies Act 2006. The company’s solvency, creditor interests and directors’ duties require particular care where profits are uncertain, accounts are outdated or losses have arisen after the last year end.

A practical process is to prepare or review relevant accounts, calculate accumulated realised profits and losses, check the articles and any shareholder agreement, approve the dividend through the correct corporate procedure, and retain the accounts, board minutes, shareholder resolution and dividend vouchers. If an error is identified, directors should establish the amount involved, assess whether the company can recover it, and take appropriate corporate and insolvency advice promptly.