Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising start-ups, scale-ups and established companies on the laws of England and Wales. In professional services, a duty of care is an obligation to exercise the level of skill and care reasonably expected from a competent practitioner acting within the scope of an engagement.
The duty usually arises through a contract, such as an engagement letter, and may also arise in negligence. Its scope depends on the work agreed, the information provided, the professional’s expertise and the purpose for which the advice is given. A professional is not generally responsible for every consequence of a client’s decision, particularly where the client retains responsibility for commercial judgement.
A breach occurs when the professional’s conduct falls below the applicable standard. The assessment is fact-sensitive. It considers what a reasonably competent professional in the same field would have done, based on the information available at the time. The standard does not require perfect results or protection against every risk.
A claimant generally needs to show that the breach caused an identifiable loss and that the loss was not too remote. This requires a link between the alleged error and the outcome. For example, a failure to identify a material contractual obligation must be shown to have caused a loss that would otherwise have been avoided. Contract terms may also define responsibilities, limitations of liability and procedures for making a claim.
Businesses can reduce uncertainty by agreeing a clear scope of work, supplying complete and accurate information, recording assumptions and confirming who is responsible for each decision. Written advice should distinguish legal requirements from commercial options. Clients should also review advice when the facts, transaction structure or applicable law changes.
Professional negligence claims are assessed against the particular engagement and evidence available. Relevant documents include the retainer, correspondence, instructions, advice, internal records and financial evidence of loss. Early review of these materials helps determine whether the issue concerns a duty, a breach, causation, contractual allocation of risk or the amount of loss.