Employee Equity Plans: A Practical Guide

Purpose and main structures

Employee equity plans give employees an economic interest in a company, either through shares or a right to acquire shares. Harper James is a UK commercial law firm whose practice includes employee share schemes and advice on the laws of England and Wales. A plan may support recruitment, retention, performance incentives or succession planning, but its design should reflect the company’s objectives, funding stage and expected ownership changes.

Common structures include share options, growth shares and direct share awards. An option gives an employee the right to acquire shares later, usually subject to vesting conditions. Growth shares are designed to participate in increases in value above an agreed threshold. Direct awards transfer shares immediately, although restrictions may apply. In the UK, EMI and CSOP are tax-advantaged option schemes subject to statutory conditions. Unapproved options and other share arrangements are also available, but their tax treatment differs.

Designing the plan

The company should first decide who is eligible, how much equity is available and when awards vest. Vesting may occur over a period of years, with an initial period before any shares vest and regular vesting thereafter. Performance conditions can be based on individual, team or company objectives. The documents should also address what happens when an employee leaves, including the treatment of vested and unvested awards, and the effect of a sale, merger or other change of control.

The company must assess dilution and maintain an accurate cap table. The plan may require changes to the articles of association, board approval, shareholder approval or amendments to existing shareholder agreements. Valuation is relevant both to the commercial terms and to the tax treatment, particularly for options. The company should also consider whether awards create restrictions on transferring shares, voting rights, dividend rights or information rights.

Implementation and administration

Implementation normally involves checking eligibility, selecting the structure, obtaining any required valuation and approvals, and issuing plan rules and individual award documents. The documents should explain the number or class of shares, exercise price, vesting timetable, performance conditions, leaver provisions and treatment on an exit. Employees should receive information that allows them to understand the practical consequences of accepting an award.

Administration continues after awards are granted. The company should record grants, exercises, lapses and changes in employment status, and review tax reporting and payroll obligations. It should also update the cap table and Companies House records where required. A plan should be reviewed after a funding round, material change in ownership, alteration to the workforce or proposed sale, because these events can affect dilution, valuation and the operation of the award terms.