Employment Tribunal Claims: A Practical Guide for Employers

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on employment and workforce restructuring under the laws of England and Wales. Employers should treat an employment tribunal claim as a legal process with strict deadlines, rather than as an extension of an internal grievance or disciplinary procedure.

First steps after receiving a claim

Check the ET1 claim form, identify each allegation, and record the relevant deadlines. Most employment claims require the claimant to complete Acas early conciliation before issuing proceedings. Many claims have a basic limitation period of three months less one day, subject to statutory extensions, including time spent in early conciliation. The employer’s response is made on form ET3 and generally must be received within 28 days of the date the claim was sent to the respondent. Missing the deadline can prevent the employer from defending the claim.

The employer should appoint one person to manage the matter, preserve relevant documents and avoid altering or deleting records. Relevant material can include emails, messages, personnel files, meeting notes, policies, performance records and payroll information. A factual chronology should be prepared, separating established evidence from disputed accounts. Managers and witnesses should be told not to discuss the case in informal channels or contact the claimant about the proceedings.

Preparing the response

The ET3 should answer each allegation clearly. It should state which facts are admitted, denied or not admitted, and explain the employer’s positive case. The response should identify jurisdictional points, such as limitation or employment status, as well as the substantive defence. Internal policies are relevant evidence, but a tribunal considers the actual facts and the employer’s conduct, not only whether a policy exists.

The tribunal will usually issue case management orders setting out steps such as disclosure of documents, preparation of a schedule of loss, exchange of witness statements and production of a hearing bundle. Employers should comply with each order by its stated deadline. A settlement agreement, Acas conciliation or judicial mediation can resolve a dispute before a final hearing, but any settlement should define the claims being settled and the payment, confidentiality and reference arrangements.

Managing risk and cost

The likely exposure should be assessed claim by claim. Compensation varies according to the type of claim and the evidence, and may include loss of earnings, injury to feelings where legally available, and other statutory remedies. Employment tribunals do not generally award legal costs to the successful party, although costs or preparation time orders are available in defined circumstances, including unreasonable conduct. The employer should therefore set a budget, review the strength of the evidence at each stage and obtain advice on pleadings, settlement and hearing preparation where the issues or potential liability justify it.