Equal Pay Reviews: A Practical Guide for Employers

Harper James advises UK employers on equal pay reviews under the laws of England and Wales, including the analysis of pay structures, job roles and potential claims. An equal pay review tests whether women and men receive equal contractual terms for equal work.

What an equal pay review covers

The Equality Act 2010 protects employees where they perform:

The comparison normally involves an actual comparator of the opposite sex who works for the same employer or an associated employer. An equal pay review differs from gender pay gap reporting. Gender pay gap reporting measures average pay differences across an organisation, while equal pay law examines whether particular employees receive different contractual terms for equal work.

A practical review process

Start by defining the scope. Collect current and historical information on salaries, bonuses, commission, overtime, allowances, benefits, working hours, location and contractual terms. Group roles by duties rather than job title, since employees with different titles may perform substantially similar work. Review recruitment records, promotion decisions, pay increases and discretionary awards to identify how differences arose.

The next stage is to compare roles and identify unexplained differences. Each difference requires a clear, evidenced explanation based on a material factor unrelated to sex, such as length of service, geographic location, market conditions or individual performance. The explanation must apply to the specific difference and remain supported by contemporaneous records. A general statement that salaries were negotiated individually is not, by itself, a sufficient review process.

Responding to findings

Where the review identifies an unjustified difference, the employer should set out a remediation plan. This can include correcting salary or benefits, reviewing bonus arrangements, adjusting job evaluation criteria and introducing clearer pay-setting controls. The organisation should also decide how to address historic losses, communicate changes and prevent the same issue recurring. Records should show the information considered, the rationale for each decision and the approval process.

Employers should treat equal pay reviews as an ongoing governance exercise rather than a one-off data check. Board or senior management oversight, consistent promotion and salary review criteria, manager training and periodic analysis of new roles help maintain a defensible pay structure. Particular care is required during restructures, acquisitions and harmonisation exercises, where changes to terms can create new comparison issues. Claims can result in compensation for arrears and interest, so early identification and accurate records are important.