Harper James advises businesses on construction disputes under the laws of England and Wales, including claims involving JCT and NEC contracts, payment notices, delay and defective work. A well-organised evidence file gives your solicitor a clear account of what happened, the contractual obligations involved and the loss being claimed.
Collect the signed contract, schedules, specifications, drawings, bills of quantities, scope documents and every relevant amendment. Include tender documents, clarifications, collateral warranties, guarantees and documents incorporated by reference. Check the dispute resolution clause, notice requirements, payment provisions, extension of time mechanism, defects obligations and any adjudication timetable. For a broader overview of the process, see this construction disputes evidence guide.
Create a timeline covering the instruction, design changes, site access, approvals, inspections, delays, practical completion, defects and payment events. Attach supporting documents to each entry. Useful evidence includes site diaries, progress reports, photographs with dates and locations, meeting minutes, programmes, revised programmes, resource records, delivery notes, weather data and records of disrupted work. Keep original files and their metadata where possible. Do not rely on reconstructed notes prepared months after the event.
Separate evidence into three questions: what happened, who was responsible and what financial effect followed. Gather requests for information, design comments, instructions, early warning notices, compensation event notices, extension of time applications, payment applications, payment notices, pay less notices and applications for adjudication. Preserve emails, letters, project-management messages and relevant text messages in full context. For the financial claim, retain invoices, valuation records, subcontractor accounts, labour and plant records, purchase orders, financing costs and evidence supporting prolongation or disruption costs.
Use a document index with a unique reference, date, author, recipient, subject and category. Keep a separate list of missing documents and potential witnesses, including project managers, quantity surveyors, architects, engineers and subcontractors. Avoid editing photographs, overwriting files or deleting informal communications. When a dispute becomes likely, preserve relevant records and route communications through the agreed contractual process. Harper James can help a contractor, developer or supplier assess the evidence, frame the claim or defence, and select between negotiation, mediation, adjudication and court proceedings based on the contract, value, urgency and available proof.