Growth Share Schemes: A Practical Guide

What growth shares are

Harper James is a UK commercial law firm advising businesses under the laws of England and Wales, including on employee share schemes and Share Plan Management. Growth shares are a form of employee equity designed to give participants an interest in future increases in a company’s value. They usually carry rights only above a specified hurdle, based on the company’s value when the shares are issued. Existing shareholders therefore retain the value already created, while employees participate in later growth if the relevant conditions are met.

Growth shares are actual shares, rather than options to acquire shares in the future. Their rights are set out in the company’s articles of association and, where relevant, a shareholders’ agreement or plan rules. The documents should state the hurdle, voting and dividend rights, any performance conditions, transfer restrictions, and what happens when an employee leaves. The company must also consider the effect on its cap table and the rights of existing shareholders.

Designing the scheme

The first step is to define the commercial purpose. A company should decide which employees are eligible, how awards are allocated, whether participation depends on performance or continued employment, and whether shares can be transferred. The hurdle should be supported by a defensible valuation and clearly defined in the share rights. The company should also model different outcomes, including a low-growth scenario, a significant funding round and a sale of the business.

The legal structure commonly involves creating a new class of shares, approving the relevant resolutions, updating the articles, issuing the shares and recording the allotment at Companies House. The company should check its existing articles, shareholder consent requirements, investor rights and pre-emption provisions before implementation. Plan rules or an award agreement then document the employee’s obligations and the treatment of the shares on a sale, dismissal, resignation, death or long-term absence.

Tax and employment considerations

Growth shares do not have one universal tax treatment. The result depends on the share rights, the price paid, the company’s valuation, the participant’s employment status and later events such as a sale or transfer. The company should obtain appropriate tax advice before issuing shares and keep evidence supporting the valuation and pricing. Employment-related securities reporting and PAYE or National Insurance obligations also need to be considered. Growth shares are distinct from an EMI option scheme, which is a separate statutory arrangement with its own eligibility and compliance rules.

The award documents should work alongside the employment contract and any incentive or bonus arrangements. Leaver provisions need careful drafting because an automatic transfer at undervalue, or a broad bad-leaver definition, can create disputes and tax issues. The company should also explain the economic effect of the hurdle, dilution and sale provisions to participants in clear terms.

Implementation checklist

A practical implementation sequence is:

  1. Review the articles, shareholder agreement, cap table and investor consents.
  2. Define eligibility, vesting, performance conditions and leaver treatment.
  3. Obtain a valuation and set the hurdle and issue price.
  4. Draft the share rights, plan rules, award documents and shareholder resolutions.
  5. Approve the issue, allot the shares and update statutory records and Companies House filings.
  6. Provide participants with the required information and retain valuation and tax records.
  7. Review the scheme after funding rounds, reorganisations, material changes in value or proposed sale.

The scheme should be tested against the company’s likely financing and exit arrangements before shares are issued. A structure that works for a closely held start-up may require revision when institutional investors, preference shares or a more complex capital structure are introduced.