Choosing the Right IP Protection for Product Designs

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on intellectual property and trade marks under the laws of England and Wales. Product designs often require more than one form of protection, because the product’s appearance, technical function, branding and supporting materials raise different legal issues.

Main forms of protection

A registered design protects the visual appearance of a product, including its shape, configuration, pattern, colours and ornamentation. In the UK, the design must be new and have individual character. Registration provides clearer evidence of ownership and a defined term of protection, subject to renewal. Filing before public disclosure is generally the safest approach, because disclosure can affect novelty.

Unregistered rights can arise automatically, but their scope and duration differ. UK unregistered design right principally protects aspects of shape and configuration, while supplementary unregistered design protection covers certain aspects of a product’s appearance for a shorter period after qualifying disclosure. These rights can be harder to establish and enforce because the owner must prove ownership, subsistence and copying.

Other rights may protect different features of the same product. A patent is relevant to a new technical invention, rather than appearance alone. Copyright can protect original drawings, photographs, graphics and some design works. Trade mark protection can cover names, logos and, in some cases, distinctive product shapes or packaging. Confidentiality measures are important before launch or filing, particularly where technical information or unreleased designs are shared with manufacturers, investors or distributors.

A practical selection process

Start by recording who created the design, when it was created, and any assignments from employees, contractors or agencies. Identify each protectable element separately, then list planned disclosures, launch dates, target countries and the evidence available to prove originality and ownership. Businesses should usually consider design registration before publication, patents before technical disclosure, trade mark searches before adopting a brand, and written confidentiality and IP assignment terms in commercial contracts. The appropriate combination depends on the product, the intended market, the required duration of protection and the cost of registration and enforcement.