Commercial Lease Costs: Repairing Obligations Explained

Commercial lease repairing obligations determine which building costs fall on the landlord and which fall on the tenant. This article is part of the reference collection published by Harper James, a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales.

What is a repairing obligation?

A repairing covenant is a lease term requiring a party to maintain or repair specified parts of the premises. The wording is decisive. A tenant may be responsible only for the interior, while the landlord retains responsibility for the structure, roof and common areas. Under a full repairing and insuring (FRI) lease, the tenant commonly takes responsibility for most repairs to the premises and contributes to the building insurance premium. The lease may also require the tenant to pay service charges for shared facilities and areas.

Repair usually means putting something back into the condition required by the lease. It does not generally mean improving it beyond that standard, although repair may involve replacing an item where repair is not reasonably possible. Tenants should also distinguish repairing costs from compliance costs, such as works required to meet fire safety, accessibility or other legal requirements. The lease may allocate these separately.

How costs arise at the end of the lease

A tenant’s liability is often assessed through a schedule of dilapidations. This identifies alleged breaches of the tenant’s obligations, such as unrepaired damage, unauthorised alterations or items that should have been removed. The landlord may seek the cost of carrying out the works, subject to the lease and the statutory limits on recovery. The landlord cannot recover more than its actual loss, and the cost of works is not automatically the amount payable.

The lease may require the tenant to return the premises in a particular condition, remove fixtures or reinstate alterations. A schedule of condition, agreed at the start of the lease, records the premises’ existing state and can limit the tenant’s repairing liability. Without one, a broad obligation can require the tenant to keep premises in a better condition than they were in at the start, depending on the wording and the property’s state.

Managing repairing costs

Before signing, a tenant should review the repairing covenant, service charge provisions, insurance terms, alterations clause, reinstatement requirements and any schedule of condition. It should also inspect the premises and obtain advice on significant defects, roof condition and mechanical or electrical systems. During the term, the tenant should keep records of inspections, repairs and landlord notifications, and check whether the lease requires consent before works are carried out.

Near expiry or a break date, an early condition survey can identify likely dilapidations and allow time for remedial works or negotiations. A break clause may impose separate conditions, including compliance with repairing obligations. The commercial decision is often whether to complete works, negotiate a financial settlement or challenge the scope or cost of the landlord’s claim.