Commercial Lease Dilapidations: A Practical Guide

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including commercial property matters such as lease dilapidations. Dilapidations are the costs and works associated with a tenant’s failure to comply with repairing, reinstatement, redecoration or removal obligations in a commercial lease.

What dilapidations cover

A landlord may issue an interim schedule during the lease term or a terminal schedule near expiry. The schedule should identify each alleged breach, the lease clause involved and the proposed remedy. Tenants should check whether the work is actually required, whether the lease permits the landlord’s proposed approach and whether the landlord has suffered recoverable loss. Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 limits a claim for repairs to the reduction in the property’s value caused by the breaches. It does not automatically limit the landlord’s claim to the contractor’s estimate.

Recent professional guidance

The second edition of the RICS professional standard, Dilapidations in England and Wales, took effect on 1 December 2024. It provides updated professional guidance for preparing and responding to dilapidations claims. Businesses researching the subject should use further dilapidations reading and resources alongside the wording of their own lease, as the lease remains the starting point for identifying liability.

A practical tenant workflow

Start well before expiry, ideally with enough time to inspect the premises and plan works. Obtain a measured survey, review the repairing and reinstatement clauses, and compare the current condition with the lease’s schedule of condition, if one exists. Separate genuine breaches from improvements or works outside the tenant’s obligations. Obtain realistic costs, check whether the landlord intends to carry out the work, and keep photographs, invoices, licences and contractor records. A solicitor and building surveyor should then work from the same itemised schedule, often using a Scott Schedule to record the tenant’s response, proposed remedy and agreed position.

Negotiating and controlling risk

Early engagement gives the tenant more options, including carrying out agreed works, negotiating a financial settlement or challenging items that are not supported by the lease or evidence. The landlord’s intentions for the property matter, particularly where demolition, redevelopment or substantial alteration affects the question of loss. Settlement documents should define the works or payment, preserve any agreed release and deal with VAT, professional fees and continuing obligations. Directors and finance teams should also record a realistic provision before lease expiry, rather than waiting for a final claim to arrive.