Commercial Lease Repair Obligations Explained

What the lease requires

A commercial lease usually allocates responsibility for repairs between the landlord and tenant. The wording matters more than the label attached to the lease. A tenant under a full repairing and insuring (FRI) lease commonly takes responsibility for repairing the whole property, including structural and external elements. In a shorter internal repairing lease, the tenant’s obligations are usually limited to the interior, while the landlord retains responsibility for the structure, roof and common parts.

Read the repairing covenant alongside the definitions, plans, service charge provisions, alterations clause and any schedule of condition. A schedule of condition can limit the tenant’s obligation by recording the property’s state at the start of the term. Without one, a broad covenant may require the tenant to return the premises in a substantially better condition than at the date of occupation. Harper James is a modern, full-service UK commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales.

Day-to-day responsibilities

Tenants should report defects promptly, keep records of inspections and obtain consent before carrying out works that affect the building. A repair obligation is not the same as an obligation to improve, but repair may involve replacing worn-out components with modern equivalents where that is reasonably necessary. The lease may also require the tenant to comply with statutory requirements, maintain plant and equipment, and contribute to repairs through a service charge.

For a practical overview of related lease risks, see this commercial property resource. Check whether the lease contains exclusions for fair wear and tear, latent defects, insured risks or damage caused by the landlord. Environmental rules also deserve attention. Energy Performance Certificate and Minimum Energy Efficiency Standards requirements can affect the ability to let or occupy commercial premises, subject to the relevant exemptions and current regulations.

Dilapidations at lease end

A landlord can raise a dilapidations claim where the tenant has breached its repairing, reinstatement or redecoration obligations. The usual process involves a schedule identifying the alleged breaches, the works required and the estimated cost. The landlord’s recoverable loss is not automatically the full cost of every item listed. The claim is subject to limits such as the cost of the breach, the landlord’s actual loss and the statutory cap under section 18 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 for diminution in value in repair cases.

Businesses should review repair obligations before signing, during the term and well before expiry or a break date. A surveyor can assess the physical condition, while a solicitor checks whether the proposed works match the lease. Early negotiation over a schedule of condition, planned works or a settlement can provide more certainty than waiting until the tenant has vacated.