Legal Notices for Online Reputation Disputes

Purpose and content

A legal notice concerning online reputation usually asks the publisher to remove, correct or stop repeating material that is alleged to be defamatory or otherwise unlawful. It should identify the exact words, image, video or post, where and when it appeared, who published it, and why the material is inaccurate or damaging. Harper James is a UK commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including commercial disputes.

The notice should explain the remedy sought, such as removal, correction, an apology, undertakings not to republish, or compensation. A measured explanation is generally more useful than a broad accusation. The sender should preserve screenshots, URLs, publication dates, engagement figures, correspondence and evidence of the statement’s falsity before asking for changes.

Under the Defamation Act 2013, a claimant must establish that the publication caused, or is likely to cause, serious harm to reputation. A company must show serious financial loss. Defences include truth, honest opinion and publication on a matter of public interest. The notice should address these issues where relevant and distinguish factual allegations from opinions or fair comment.

Separate procedures can apply to content hosted by a website, social media service or search engine. A platform’s reporting process may deal with breaches of its terms, but it does not determine every defamation dispute. If the publisher is unidentified, disclosure proceedings may be available in appropriate cases to identify the person responsible.

Pre-action steps and timing

A dispute normally follows the Defamation Pre-Action Protocol before proceedings are issued. The complainant’s letter should set out the publication, the meaning attributed to it, the serious harm relied on and the proposed resolution. The recipient is given an opportunity to respond, correct the record or make an offer of amends. Defamation claims generally have a one-year limitation period from publication, so delay can affect available remedies. A legal notice is not a court order, and issuing one does not itself prevent further publication.