Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including commercial contracts. Liability should be assessed before drafting begins by reviewing the contract’s subject matter, the parties’ roles, likely loss scenarios, insurance position and ability to control the relevant risk. This helps distinguish ordinary performance risk from higher-risk issues such as data breaches, intellectual property infringement, confidentiality breaches, personal injury or regulatory non-compliance.
A limitation clause commonly sets an aggregate financial cap, such as a fixed amount or a multiple of the fees paid under the contract. The drafting should state whether the cap applies to all claims together or separately to each claim, contract year or event. Specific risks can have separate “super caps”, while some liabilities are excluded from the cap entirely. Exclusions for indirect or consequential loss should be drafted carefully because those terms can be interpreted narrowly and disputes often concern whether a particular loss falls within them.
A liability cap should identify the liabilities that are not limited. Under the law of England and Wales, a party cannot generally exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence, or for fraud or fraudulent misrepresentation. Other common carve-outs include confidentiality breaches, misuse of intellectual property, deliberate wrongdoing, unpaid charges and data protection obligations. The contract should also state how indemnities, warranties and service credits interact with the main liability cap, rather than leaving their relationship unclear.
A limitation clause must be incorporated into the contract and drafted in clear, prominent terms. Where the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 applies, certain exclusions and restrictions in business contracts must satisfy a reasonableness test. Factors include the parties’ bargaining positions, the availability of insurance and whether the relevant term was brought to the other party’s attention. Before signing, each party should compare the proposed cap with the contract value, foreseeable exposure and available insurance, then record any agreed exclusions, notice periods, mitigation duties and claims procedure.