Harper James advises businesses on commercial disputes under the laws of England and Wales, including the planning and control of litigation spend. Managing costs begins with assessing the value of the claim, the available evidence, the likely defences and the commercial objective, rather than treating court proceedings as the default outcome.
A written case assessment should identify the legal issues, key documents, witnesses, limitation dates and possible remedies. It should also separate recoverable litigation costs from internal management time, disruption to operations, expert fees, barrister’s fees, court fees and the cost of preserving and reviewing documents. The solicitor and client can then agree a phased budget covering pre-action correspondence, pleadings, disclosure, witness evidence, expert evidence, trial preparation and the hearing.
Budgets are more useful when they include assumptions and decision points. For example, the business can set a review after receiving the opponent’s defence, completing disclosure or obtaining an expert report. At each stage, the parties can compare further expenditure with the value of the claim, the prospects of success and the business impact of continuing.
Early settlement discussions, mediation and structured negotiation often reduce the cost and management time associated with a trial. A settlement proposal should address not only the principal sum but also interest, legal costs, confidentiality, payment timing and any continuing obligations. Part 36 offers have specific costs consequences under the Civil Procedure Rules, so their wording and timing require careful consideration.
Procedural discipline also affects cost. Parties should comply with court directions, limit disclosure to relevant documents, use proportionate evidence and avoid unnecessary interlocutory applications. A failure to comply with directions can result in adverse costs orders, wasted work or restrictions on the evidence a party can rely on.
Commercial litigation is usually funded by the business from its own resources, but available arrangements also include staged or fixed fees for defined work, conditional fee agreements in suitable cases, litigation funding and after-the-event insurance. Each arrangement has different eligibility requirements, costs and effects on control of the litigation.
In England and Wales, the general principle is that the unsuccessful party pays a proportion of the successful party’s costs, subject to the court’s discretion and detailed assessment. Recovery is not automatic and is rarely complete. A business should therefore make decisions using its own likely spend as well as the amount it expects to recover, and record key cost decisions throughout the dispute.