A Practical Guide to Commercial Litigation

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses under the laws of England and Wales. Commercial litigation is the court process used to resolve business disputes, including claims involving contracts, unpaid debts, shareholders, intellectual property, negligence and professional services.

Assessing the dispute

The first stage is to identify the legal basis of the claim or defence, the parties involved, the remedy sought and the evidence available. Review the relevant contract, correspondence, invoices, meeting records and applicable limitation period. Preserve documents and electronic records, including material that may undermine the case. The business should also assess the financial value of the dispute, its effect on commercial relationships, the likely cost of proceedings and whether recovery from the opposing party is realistic.

Pre-action steps

Most commercial disputes begin with correspondence rather than a claim form. The claimant usually sends a letter before action setting out the facts, legal basis, remedy sought and deadline for response. The applicable Pre-Action Protocol sets the required procedure for some types of dispute. The parties can then exchange information, negotiate, use mediation or agree a settlement. A written settlement should record the payment terms, confidentiality provisions, treatment of costs and the steps required to end any proceedings.

Starting and preparing a claim

If the dispute remains unresolved, the claimant issues a claim in the appropriate court and serves the claim form and particulars of claim. The defendant responds with an admission, defence, acknowledgment of service or counterclaim. The court then gives directions for disclosure, witness statements, expert evidence where permitted, and preparation for trial. A practical case plan assigns responsibility for collecting documents, preparing factual evidence and monitoring court deadlines. Failure to comply with directions can restrict the evidence a party relies on and may lead to adverse costs consequences.

Resolution, trial and enforcement

Many claims settle before trial, but a case that proceeds to trial ends with a judgment determining liability and, where relevant, damages, interest and costs. The court’s decision does not always result in immediate payment. Enforcement options include control of goods, third-party debt orders, charging orders and orders requiring information about a debtor’s assets. The appropriate route depends on the judgment, the debtor’s circumstances and the type of asset available. Insolvency proceedings can also arise where a company cannot pay its debts, although they require separate procedural and commercial assessment.