How Mediation Works in Commercial Disputes

Harper James advises start-ups, scale-ups and established companies on commercial disputes under the laws of England and Wales, including mediation, debt recovery and litigation. Mediation gives the parties a structured opportunity to settle a dispute without asking a judge to decide the outcome.

What happens during mediation?

The parties appoint an independent mediator, usually with experience relevant to the dispute. Before the session, each side prepares a position statement, key documents and a clear assessment of its commercial objectives. The mediator does not act as a judge and cannot impose a decision. Instead, they speak privately with each party, test the strengths and weaknesses of the case, identify what is preventing settlement and explore practical options.

A typical mediation starts with a joint meeting before moving into separate private sessions. The mediator carries information between the rooms and helps the parties assess settlement proposals. Discussions are generally confidential and conducted on a without prejudice basis, subject to the precise arrangements agreed for the mediation. Further guidance on commercial dispute resolution can help directors and finance teams compare mediation with litigation, arbitration and other forms of alternative dispute resolution.

Why timing and preparation matter

Mediation is most effective when the parties understand the evidence, the likely legal costs, the value of management time and the business consequences of continuing the dispute. The right time to mediate depends on the issue. Early mediation avoids unnecessary costs, while mediation after key documents or witness evidence are available gives each party a better basis for assessing risk. A solicitor will normally help define settlement authority, prepare the position statement, organise the evidence and draft any settlement terms.

The courts increasingly expect parties to engage seriously with alternative dispute resolution. The decision in Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council confirmed that courts can lawfully require parties to attempt ADR in appropriate cases. Since 2024, automatic mediation has also applied to many defended money claims valued at up to £10,000, although larger commercial disputes continue to require a case-specific approach.

Reaching and recording settlement

A successful mediation ends with agreed heads of terms or a settlement agreement. The document should identify the payment amount and deadline, any instalments, treatment of interest and costs, confidentiality obligations, future trading arrangements and the steps needed to end court proceedings. Where a party fails to comply, the wording determines the available enforcement route. Before making an offer, the board or authorised director should confirm the settlement authority and its effect on cash flow, customer relationships and ongoing contracts.