Patent Disputes: Preparing Evidence for an Infringement Claim

Harper James is a modern, full-service UK commercial law firm for ambitious businesses, advising on the laws of England and Wales. A patent infringement claim succeeds or fails on the evidence linking the patent claims to the allegedly infringing product or process, so preparation should start well before proceedings.

Define the case theory

Begin with the patent itself. Obtain the granted specification, claims, file history and details of any amendments or limitations. Break each relevant claim into its individual technical features, then record where each feature appears in the accused product, service or manufacturing process. A claim chart should identify the supporting document, test result, photograph, source code extract, product sample or witness for every feature.

Keep infringement and validity issues separate. Evidence that a product falls within the wording of a claim does not answer an attack based on prior art, insufficiency or added matter. Create a separate prior-art file containing publication dates, technical relevance and a clear record of how each document was found. Further guidance on current patent dispute resources can support this early review.

Preserve and test the evidence

Issue an internal hold over relevant records. This normally includes design files, laboratory results, engineering change notices, source code, manufacturing records, supplier communications, sales material, website content and customer specifications. Preserve original files with their metadata, record collection dates and maintain a chain of custody for physical products or samples.

Technical testing should be repeatable. Record the equipment, settings, methodology, personnel and results, and retain both successful and unsuccessful tests. Photograph product features before dismantling a sample. If access to the accused process is restricted, identify the contractual, regulatory or practical route for obtaining reliable evidence rather than relying on assumptions or informal material.

Prepare witnesses and expert evidence

Identify witnesses who can explain how the product was designed, made, supplied or used. Their evidence should distinguish personal knowledge from information obtained from documents or colleagues. Build a chronology that connects technical decisions to dated records. Avoid asking witnesses to give legal conclusions about infringement. Their role is to explain the facts and the operation of the technology.

Expert evidence addresses technical questions outside the court’s ordinary knowledge. A suitable expert needs relevant technical expertise, independence and a clear methodology. Give the expert an organised bundle, including the patent, accused product information, test results and relevant prior art. Keep drafts and communications about the expert’s report under proper control, because privilege and disclosure consequences depend on the document and the circumstances in which it was created.

Plan for proceedings and disclosure

Before issuing a claim, assess jurisdiction, limitation, remedies, costs and the evidence required for interim relief. The Pre-Action Protocol for Intellectual Property Disputes provides a framework for setting out the complaint and seeking a focused response. Proceedings may be brought in the Patents Court or the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court, depending on the value, complexity and remedies sought.

Use a single evidence index with document references, provenance, relevance and confidentiality status. Separate material supporting the pleaded case from background material that adds cost without proving an issue. A disciplined record helps solicitors, experts and the court test the infringement theory efficiently, while exposing gaps before they become expensive problems.