Harper James is a modern, full-service UK commercial law firm advising ambitious businesses on the laws of England and Wales. A patent infringement assessment should establish whether a proposed product, process or service falls within the claims of a valid patent, and what practical steps reduce commercial exposure.
Define the product and the markets in which it will be made, used, sold or imported. Search the UKIPO register, Espacenet and relevant international databases, then check each patent’s number, owner, priority date, grant status, renewal position and territorial coverage. A patent granted elsewhere does not automatically create infringement risk in the UK. The UK is also outside the Unified Patent Court and Unitary Patent system, so those rights do not themselves extend to the UK.
A useful patent risk assessment guide can support the initial review. Keep a record of search terms, relevant patent families and excluded results. Patent databases contain valuable technical information, but search results are not a substitute for analysing the legal claims.
Read the independent claims first. Break each claim into its required technical features and create a claim chart showing where each feature appears in the proposed product or process. In the UK, infringement under section 60 of the Patents Act 1977 includes making, disposing of, offering to dispose of, using, importing or keeping a patented product in the course of business. It also covers certain uses of patented processes and products obtained directly through those processes.
The assessment should address direct infringement, possible indirect infringement, available licences and the patent’s validity. UK courts interpret claims purposively and also consider whether an act falls within the scope of a patent as an equivalent under the approach developed in Actavis v Eli Lilly. That makes a close technical comparison essential, even where the product does not copy the wording or design exactly.
Classify each identified patent as a high, medium or low priority based on claim overlap, validity concerns, commercial importance, enforcement history and the cost of changing the design. Options include redesigning a feature, obtaining a licence, delaying launch, seeking an opinion, challenging validity or proceeding with a documented risk position. Preserve technical drawings, development records and design decisions, since these may become relevant in later discussions or proceedings.
A sound assessment is refreshed when the product changes, a new patent is granted, ownership changes or a business enters a new territory. It should also be completed before public launch, major procurement activity or investment due diligence. This creates a practical record of the decision, rather than relying on a broad statement that the product is “different” from an existing patent.