Harper James advises UK businesses on employment law, including the distinction between gender pay gap reporting and equal pay obligations under the laws of England and Wales. Although the terms are often used together, they describe different legal and statistical issues.
Equal pay requires men and women to receive equal contractual pay for equal work. The comparison concerns work that is the same, broadly similar, or of equal value in terms of factors such as skill, effort, responsibility and working conditions. Pay includes salary, bonuses, overtime, benefits and some forms of share-related remuneration.
The Equality Act 2010 generally requires employers to identify and correct unequal pay. An employer can defend a difference where it results from a genuine material factor unrelated to sex, such as experience, location, performance or a properly evidenced recruitment premium. The reason must be objective and consistently applied.
The gender pay gap measures the difference between the average pay of men and women across an organisation. It is usually reported using both the mean and median hourly pay gap, together with figures for bonuses and the proportion of men and women in each pay quartile. The gap often reflects workforce composition, including the representation of women in senior, highly paid roles and the distribution of part-time work.
A gender pay gap does not, by itself, prove an equal pay breach. An organisation can have equal pay for comparable roles while retaining a gap caused by occupational structure. Conversely, an employer can have no overall gender pay gap while individual employees still have unequal pay claims.
Employers should maintain accurate role descriptions, salary bands and records of bonuses and benefits. A structured pay audit should compare employees performing equal work, test whether differences have an objective explanation, and review recruitment, promotion, flexible working and progression data. Employers with at least 250 employees are generally required to publish annual gender pay gap information under the UK reporting regime. The results should be checked for data errors and accompanied by a clear explanation of causes and planned actions. Where unequal pay is identified, the employer should investigate promptly, correct the position and address any related contractual or employee-relations issues.