Pre-Action Protocols: A Business Guide

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales. Pre-action protocols set out the steps parties should generally take before starting civil court proceedings, with the aim of defining the dispute, encouraging settlement and reducing avoidable costs.

What a pre-action protocol does

A relevant protocol usually requires the potential claimant to send a detailed letter of claim. This sets out the facts, legal basis of the claim, remedy sought and, where relevant, the documents relied on and a calculation of loss. The proposed defendant should acknowledge the letter and provide a reasoned response within the applicable timetable. The response should state which allegations are admitted, denied or not admitted, and explain any denial.

Different protocols apply to different disputes, including construction and engineering claims, professional negligence, debt claims and claims involving businesses or individuals. Where no specific protocol applies, the general principles in the Practice Direction on Pre-Action Conduct and Protocols are relevant. The parties should identify the correct procedure before sending correspondence, because an unsuitable or incomplete letter can create delay and cost issues.

Managing the process

A business should preserve relevant contracts, emails, meeting notes, invoices, technical records and internal decisions as soon as a dispute is identified. It should also establish the key dates, including contractual notice periods and the limitation deadline. Following a pre-action timetable does not usually stop limitation from running, so a party should not assume that negotiations extend the time for issuing a claim.

The parties are expected to exchange enough information to understand each other's position and consider settlement. That may involve a without-prejudice meeting, mediation or a commercial proposal. A business should assess the value of the claim, the strength of its evidence, the likely cost of proceedings and the commercial effect of continuing the dispute before choosing a settlement position.

Responding to a letter of claim

A recipient should acknowledge the letter, check whether it identifies a valid contractual or legal basis, and gather the documents needed for a substantive response. If more time is required, it is better to request a specific extension promptly and explain why. The response should address each material allegation rather than giving a general denial.

If the parties cannot resolve the dispute, the claimant may issue court proceedings once the relevant protocol steps have been completed. A court can take a party's conduct during the pre-action stage into account when dealing with case management and costs. Failure to provide information, ignoring correspondence or issuing proceedings prematurely can therefore affect the court's approach to the case, even where the underlying claim remains arguable.