Preference Payments: A Practical Guide for Directors

What is a preference payment?

Harper James is a UK commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales. A preference payment arises when a company, while insolvent or approaching insolvency, does something that puts a creditor, guarantor or surety in a better position if the company later enters liquidation or administration than that person would otherwise have occupied.

Under section 239 of the Insolvency Act 1986, the transaction must also have been influenced by a desire to prefer that person. The relevant period is generally six months before the onset of insolvency, extending to two years where the recipient is connected with the company. A connected recipient includes certain directors, shareholders and associated persons. The transaction does not need to be a cash payment. Repaying a director’s loan, granting security for an existing debt or paying a related company can all require review.

What directors should assess

Directors should first establish the company’s financial position when the transaction was made. Relevant evidence includes cash-flow forecasts, management accounts, unpaid creditor reports, borrowing arrangements and balance-sheet information. They should then identify the recipient, the company’s relationship with that person, the reason for the transaction and whether comparable creditors were treated differently.

A payment made in the ordinary course of business is not automatically lawful. The company’s purpose, the surrounding communications and the director’s knowledge of the financial position are relevant. If the company was insolvent or nearing insolvency, directors must give proper weight to creditors’ interests and avoid using company assets to favour themselves or another creditor without a sound commercial basis.

Practical steps before making a payment

Before approving an unusual payment, the board should record the company’s financial position, the commercial reason for the payment, the alternatives considered and the effect on other creditors. The board should obtain current financial information, consider whether the payment preserves a genuine business benefit, and document why the decision is consistent with the company’s duties.

If insolvency is a real prospect, directors should preserve accounting records, avoid creating new security for old debts without proper assessment, and take advice on restructuring, a company voluntary arrangement, administration or liquidation. A payment that has already been made should be disclosed promptly to the company’s insolvency advisers, together with the board minutes and supporting documents.

Consequences of a preference

An office-holder can apply to the court for an order restoring the position that would have existed without the preference. The order can require the recipient to repay money, return property, release security or account for a benefit. The company’s directors are not automatically personally liable simply because they authorised a payment, but personal exposure can arise where there is a separate breach of duty, misfeasance, wrongful trading or another legal basis. The safest approach is to identify unusual payments early and make decisions using current financial information, consistent treatment of creditors and a clear written record.