Patent Damages and Accounts of Profits: A Practical Guide

The two principal financial remedies

Under the law of England and Wales, a patent owner who proves infringement can generally seek damages or an account of profits, as well as other remedies such as an injunction or a declaration. Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on the laws of England and Wales, including intellectual property and commercial disputes.

Damages compensate the patent owner for loss caused by the infringement. The assessment may consider lost sales, reduced prices, lost licensing income, or a reasonable royalty for use of the patent. The relevant approach depends on the evidence and the commercial circumstances. The claimant must establish a causal link between the infringement and the loss claimed, and must avoid recovering twice for the same loss.

An account of profits has a different purpose. It requires the infringer to account for the profits attributable to the infringement, rather than compensating the patent owner for its own loss. The court assesses the revenue generated by the infringing activity and deducts properly attributable costs. It then separates profit arising from the patented feature from profit attributable to other elements of the product, business or market. The remedy is discretionary and is not intended to punish the infringer.

Choosing between the remedies

A patent owner normally elects between damages and an account of profits after liability has been established and before the financial remedy is assessed. The choice is therefore an important litigation decision. Damages may be appropriate where the owner has strong evidence of lost sales, licensing value or market impact. An account may be considered where the infringer’s profits are substantial and the claimant’s own loss is difficult to quantify. The financial result cannot be assumed from the infringer’s total turnover, because only profit attributable to the infringement is relevant.

The decision should be based on available documents and commercial evidence. Useful material includes sales and pricing records, product specifications, licence agreements, royalty rates, customer data, cost allocations, market evidence and information about non-infringing alternatives. Parties should also examine the patent’s validity, the scope of the claims, the period of infringement and any limitation issues before incurring the cost of a detailed inquiry.

A practical assessment process

A structured process usually begins by defining the infringing acts and relevant period. The claimant then identifies the preferred damages model and the evidence needed to support it. If an account of profits is selected, the analysis focuses on revenue, direct and indirect costs, the contribution of the patented invention, and any non-infringing features. Expert accounting evidence is often required, particularly where products contain several technical and commercial components.

The parties should keep damages issues separate from arguments about liability where possible. Early requests for targeted disclosure can clarify sales volumes, pricing, production costs and licensing arrangements. Settlement discussions are also more productive when each side has a transparent model showing the assumptions, evidence and range of possible outcomes. A claim for damages or an account of profits should be pleaded with enough detail to identify the remedy sought, while recognising that the final calculation may depend on disclosure and expert analysis.