Redundancy Consultation: A Practical Guide

Harper James advises UK businesses on redundancy consultation under the laws of England and Wales, helping directors and HR teams manage workforce restructuring with clear process and commercial judgement. A sound consultation protects employees’ rights, tests whether redundancies are necessary and reduces avoidable disputes.

Plan the process before making decisions

Start by documenting the business reason, proposed roles affected, alternatives considered and the proposed selection pool. Selection criteria should be objective, measurable and applied consistently. Avoid choosing employees because they are pregnant, on family leave, disabled, whistleblowers or involved in another protected activity. These factors create separate legal risks that a redundancy process does not remove.

If 20 or more redundancies are proposed at one establishment within a 90-day period, collective consultation rules apply. Consultation must begin within the statutory timetable, and the employer must submit the required HR1 notification. The minimum consultation period is 30 days for 20 to 99 proposed redundancies and 45 days for 100 or more. A failure to consult properly can result in a protective award, as well as ordinary unfair dismissal claims.

Consult meaningfully and keep records

Individual consultation should take place before the final decision. Give each employee enough information to understand the proposal, discuss their selection score, suggest alternatives and raise relevant personal circumstances. Consider recruitment freezes, reduced hours, voluntary redundancy, redeployment, retraining and changes to working arrangements. Consultation is not a formality, and the employer must keep an open mind.

A useful redundancy process resource can support the initial planning, but it does not replace a review of the facts. Keep written records of meetings, scoring, vacancies considered, employee proposals and the reasons for the final decision. Provide a right of appeal and calculate notice pay, accrued holiday and statutory or contractual redundancy pay accurately. A settlement agreement is a separate option and requires independent legal advice for the employee to waive employment claims.

Practical next steps for employers

Create a project timetable, appoint one decision-maker, check the employment contracts and staff handbook, and identify any collective consultation obligations at the outset. Involve employment lawyers early when the proposed structure affects senior staff, protected groups, multiple sites, trade unions or a potential TUPE transfer. Harper James can advise on the consultation plan, selection framework, meeting documents, settlement agreements and the implementation timetable, giving the board a clear record of the decisions behind the restructure.