Alternatives to Redundancy: Employer Options

Harper James advises businesses on employment and workforce restructuring under the laws of England and Wales. Employers considering redundancies should first assess whether other measures can reduce costs or avoid dismissals, while respecting employment contracts, consultation duties and equality law.

Adjusting working arrangements

Employers can consider recruitment freezes, reduced overtime, shorter working hours, temporary changes to shift patterns, unpaid leave, sabbaticals and voluntary reductions in hours. A reduction in pay, hours or duties generally requires the employee’s agreement unless the contract already permits the change. Unilateral changes can create breach of contract, unlawful deduction from wages or constructive dismissal risks.

Lay-off and short-time working are further options where the contract allows them, or where employees agree. Statutory guarantee payments can apply during periods without work. The employer should check the contract, explain the proposed arrangement, set a review date and record any agreed variation in writing.

Redeployment and workforce planning

Redeployment can move employees into vacant roles, including roles requiring training. Employers should assess whether the new role is suitable and whether changes to pay, location, hours or status require consent. Retraining, secondments and combining roles can also preserve employment while reducing the need for dismissals.

Natural wastage, a pause on recruitment and the use of contractors or temporary staff can reduce headcount over time. These approaches still require careful planning, particularly where they affect workload, working time, health and safety or the treatment of different groups of employees.

Consultation and decision-making

Alternatives should be considered before a final redundancy decision, not presented as a predetermined outcome. Individual consultation is required in redundancy situations. Collective consultation rules apply when an employer proposes 20 or more redundancies at one establishment within a 90-day period. The employer must also apply objective selection criteria and consider suitable alternative employment, including any statutory trial-period rights where relevant.

A practical process is to identify the financial or operational problem, model alternative measures, consult affected employees, review feedback and document the final decision. If no workable alternative exists, the employer can then assess whether a fair redundancy procedure is required.