How to Structure Employee Reward Schemes

Harper James advises UK businesses on structuring employee reward schemes under the laws of England and Wales. A well-designed scheme links the reward to a clear business purpose, sets measurable conditions and records how decisions are made.

Define the purpose and reward

Start by deciding what the scheme is intended to achieve. A cash bonus may support short-term performance, while an employee share scheme is generally designed to retain staff and align them with longer-term business growth. Other options include commission, additional benefits, recognition awards, growth shares and an EMI option scheme for qualifying companies and employees.

Set out eligibility before selecting the reward. The scheme should state which employees qualify, whether part-time or employees on family leave are included, how joiners and leavers are treated, and whether service requirements apply. Criteria must be applied consistently and reviewed for discrimination risks under the Equality Act 2010.

Set measurable conditions

The rules should identify the performance measures, the measurement period and the method for calculating any reward. Measures may include revenue, profit, customer retention, project delivery or individual objectives. Avoid measures that are unclear, entirely within one manager's discretion or capable of being changed retrospectively without a defined process.

The documentation should explain when the reward becomes payable or vests, how sickness, garden leave, dismissal and resignation affect entitlement, and when the business can withhold or recover a payment. Bonus wording requires particular care. A contractual bonus creates an enforceable entitlement if its conditions are met, while a genuinely discretionary scheme still requires decisions to be made consistently and without unlawful discrimination.

Document, communicate and review

Cash schemes are usually documented in a bonus or commission plan, supported by employment contract wording and payroll processes. Share-based schemes require additional corporate and tax work. An EMI option scheme requires eligibility checks, option documentation, share valuation and appropriate records. Growth shares and other arrangements need tailored articles of association, shareholder approvals and provisions covering leavers, transfers and an exit.

The employer should explain the scheme in plain language and keep evidence of objectives, calculations and decisions. Review the scheme at least annually to confirm that the measures remain relevant, payments are affordable, and the terms continue to reflect the company's structure and tax position. Employment, tax, company law and equality considerations need to be assessed together before the scheme is implemented.