Employee Share Scheme Records: A Practical Guide

Harper James advises UK businesses on employee share schemes and the records needed to support their operation under the laws of England and Wales. Accurate records help a company demonstrate how awards were approved, issued, exercised and taxed, particularly where it operates an EMI or CSOP scheme.

Records to create at the outset

The record set should begin with the scheme rules, shareholder approvals, board minutes and any required amendments to the articles of association. For each participant, retain the grant letter or option agreement, the number and class of shares covered, the exercise price, vesting conditions, performance conditions, grant date and expiry date. The company should also record whether the award is an EMI option, CSOP option, unapproved option or another form of share plan.

For EMI schemes, the company should retain the agreed or determined market value, supporting valuation correspondence and evidence that the relevant conditions were met at the date of grant. Companies should submit required notifications to HMRC and keep confirmation of those submissions. The same principle applies to annual Employment Related Securities, or ERS, returns, which must be filed for reportable arrangements by the applicable deadline, even where no reportable event occurred in the year if an active scheme remains registered.

Maintaining the register

A central schedule should show every grant from issue to expiry, exercise, cancellation or lapse. It should identify the participant, grant date, quantity, vesting status, exercise price, restrictions, leaver treatment and outstanding balance. The schedule should reconcile with the statutory register of members, Companies House filings where relevant, payroll records and the company’s cap table.

When an employee leaves, the company should record the leaving date, the reason for departure where relevant to the scheme rules, the treatment of vested and unvested awards, the deadline for exercise and any notice given to the participant. On exercise, retain the exercise notice, payment evidence, share issue or transfer documents, updated shareholder records and tax or payroll calculations. Records should also cover share buybacks, cancellations, transfers and changes to scheme terms.

Governance and review

Access to scheme records should be restricted, with a clear owner responsible for updates and version control. The company should review the register after each board meeting, funding round, share issue, employee departure and annual ERS filing. A periodic reconciliation can identify differences between the option schedule, payroll, cap table and statutory books before they affect a funding round, audit or sale.

The retention period should reflect tax, company law, employment and data protection requirements. Records should be kept in a secure system that allows the business to retrieve the history of each award, including superseded documents. Before making grants or changing a scheme, the board should check the effect on existing participants, shareholder consent requirements, tax treatment and the company’s reporting obligations.