Settlement Agreements: A Practical Guide for Employers

Harper James is a UK full-service commercial law firm advising businesses on employment matters under the laws of England and Wales. A settlement agreement is a legally binding contract in which an employee agrees not to pursue specified employment claims, usually in return for agreed financial or other terms.

When to use a settlement agreement

Employers commonly use settlement agreements to resolve an existing dispute, manage an agreed departure, or bring an employment relationship to an orderly end. The agreement must identify the particular claims being waived. A general statement that the employee gives up “all claims” is not sufficient.

Before making an offer, the employer should identify the business objective, assess the relevant legal risks, and decide which terms are commercially appropriate. A discussion may take place as a protected conversation under section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996, although that protection does not cover every type of claim, including discrimination and whistleblowing claims. The employer should avoid presenting the proposal as a predetermined dismissal or using improper pressure.

What the agreement must contain

For a settlement agreement to waive statutory employment claims, it must be in writing, relate to a specific complaint or proceedings, and confirm that the statutory conditions have been satisfied. The employee must receive advice from an independent adviser, such as a qualified lawyer or authorised trade union representative. The agreement must identify the adviser and confirm that the required insurance or other applicable conditions are met.

Commercial terms often cover the termination date, notice or payment in lieu of notice, salary and benefits, accrued holiday, an ex-gratia payment, pension arrangements, the return of company property, confidentiality, post-termination restrictions, and an agreed reference. The employer should also specify whether payments are subject to deductions for tax and National Insurance. The first £30,000 of certain qualifying termination payments is generally exempt from income tax, but contractual payments and some other elements are treated differently.

Managing the process

The employer should give the employee reasonable time to consider the proposal and allow access to independent advice. The agreement normally includes a contribution towards the employee’s legal fees, with the amount and payment conditions stated clearly. It should also set out what happens if the employee does not sign, including whether existing disciplinary, grievance, performance or redundancy processes continue.

Once signed, the parties should follow the agreement precisely. This includes making payments on time, issuing agreed documents, providing the reference in the agreed form, and observing confidentiality and announcement provisions. A carefully documented process reduces uncertainty, but it does not prevent claims that fall outside the agreement or arise from events after it is signed.