Share Classes: Rights and Protections for Founders and Investors

Harper James advises start-ups, scale-ups and established companies on share structures under the laws of England and Wales. Share classes determine how ownership, voting power, dividends and exit proceeds are allocated, so the structure should be agreed before issuing shares or completing an investment round.

Common share classes

Ordinary shares usually carry voting rights, entitlement to dividends when declared and a share of surplus assets on a winding-up. Founders and employees commonly hold ordinary shares, although the rights can differ between ordinary classes. Preference shares give investors priority over ordinary shareholders for specified payments, often through a liquidation preference or preferential dividend. They may also carry voting rights on certain matters, full voting rights or no voting rights, depending on the articles of association and investment documents.

A company can create different classes with rights set out in its articles. The rights should cover voting, dividends, transfers, conversion, redemption and participation on a sale or winding-up. The Companies Act 2006 contains procedures for varying class rights. Unless the articles provide a different threshold, approval generally requires consent from holders of at least 75% in nominal value of the affected class, or a special resolution passed by that class.

Investor protections

Investors commonly seek reserved matters, which require their consent before the company takes specified actions. These matters can include issuing new shares, changing the articles, taking substantial borrowing, selling a material part of the business, declaring dividends or entering transactions with directors. Investors also seek information rights, board appointment or observer rights, pre-emption rights on new issues and anti-dilution provisions. Anti-dilution terms adjust an investor’s entitlement after a later issue at a lower price, subject to the agreed formula and exclusions.

Exit provisions are usually addressed in the shareholders’ agreement and articles. Tag-along rights allow minority shareholders to sell alongside a shareholder selling control. Drag-along rights allow a specified majority to require other shareholders to sell on the same terms, which assists a buyer seeking the whole company. Transfer restrictions, rights of first refusal and permitted transfer provisions govern sales between shareholders, group companies and family trusts. The documents should also state how conflicts between the articles and shareholders’ agreement are managed, since the articles bind the company and its members as a statutory contract.

Founder protections and implementation

Founders generally focus on retaining voting control, protecting operational decision-making and avoiding unexpected dilution. Protections include founder consent over defined reserved matters, weighted voting rights where appropriate, board appointment rights and pre-emption on transfers or new issues. These rights need to be balanced against investor requirements and should not prevent the company from raising further capital. The term sheet, cap table, articles, shareholders’ agreement and subscription agreement should use consistent definitions and percentages. Before completion, the company should confirm allotment authority, pre-emption disapplication, Companies House filings and the treatment of existing share options. A clear structure records both the economic bargain and the circumstances in which control changes.