Understanding Employee Share Scheme Tax

Employee share schemes give employees shares or rights to acquire shares in their employer. The tax treatment depends on the type of scheme, the value of the award, the employee’s circumstances and what happens when the shares are acquired or sold. Harper James advises businesses on employee share schemes under the laws of England and Wales.

Approved share schemes

The main tax-advantaged schemes include Enterprise Management Incentives (EMI), Company Share Option Plans (CSOP), Save As You Earn (SAYE) and Share Incentive Plans (SIP). Each has its own eligibility rules, limits and holding-period conditions. For example, an EMI option is generally structured so that income tax is not charged when the option is exercised, provided the relevant conditions are met and the exercise price reflects the required valuation. CSOP and SAYE options also have specific rules governing when tax advantages apply. A disposal of the shares can create a capital gains tax liability.

Unapproved awards and share acquisitions

Awards outside an approved scheme are commonly taxed as employment income when the employee receives shares or exercises an option. The taxable amount is generally linked to the market value of the shares, less any amount paid by the employee. Income tax and employee National Insurance contributions can arise, while the employer may have reporting and employer National Insurance obligations. Growth shares, restricted shares and arrangements involving loan notes or forfeiture conditions require careful analysis because the tax point can depend on the legal structure and the restrictions attached to the award.

Administration and key checks

Employers normally need to keep accurate records of grants, valuations, exercise dates, share restrictions and disposals. Employment Related Securities reporting to HM Revenue and Customs is generally required by 6 July following the end of the relevant tax year, including where an award has no immediate tax charge. Before implementing a scheme, a business should check employee eligibility, company eligibility, the intended tax treatment, valuation evidence, the articles of association and the shareholder agreement. Tax rules and thresholds change, so the scheme documents and reporting process should be reviewed against the rules applying at the time of each transaction.