Managing Employee Share Schemes in Growing Businesses

Harper James advises ambitious UK businesses on structuring and managing employee share schemes under the laws of England and Wales. A well-run scheme supports recruitment and retention, while giving founders and investors a clear record of who owns what and when rights arise.

Choose the right structure

An EMI option scheme is often the first option for qualifying companies, as it offers employees a tax-advantaged route to shares. Eligibility depends on the company’s activities, size, assets and the individual’s role. Where EMI is unavailable, businesses commonly consider growth shares, unapproved options or a company share plan. Each structure has different rules on valuation, vesting, leavers, dilution and tax. The board should agree the commercial purpose before selecting the documents. For a wider overview of the legal and operational issues, see this share scheme resource.

Build administration into the process

The scheme should connect with the articles of association, shareholders’ agreement, employment terms and cap table. Documents need to state vesting conditions, exercise periods, good and bad leaver treatment, performance targets and what happens on a sale. The company also needs a process for board approvals, option grants, employee communications, share certificates and Companies House records where relevant. EMI schemes require HMRC notifications and annual reporting, with the employment-related securities return generally due by 6 July after the end of the tax year.

Review the scheme as the business grows

A scheme designed for ten employees often fails when the company reaches one hundred. Review the valuation, dilution headroom, unallocated options, new funding terms and international workforce before each funding round. Investors will examine the option pool during due diligence, and buyers will expect clean records, signed agreements and consistent treatment of leavers. Harper James provides Share Plan Management as a fixed-fee product, alongside project-based advice through Engage or broader support through Enable and Extend.