Harper James advises UK start-ups, scale-ups and established companies on employee share schemes under the laws of England and Wales. A sound valuation gives employees a fair incentive, supports the company’s tax position and gives the board a defensible basis for approving options or shares.
Start by identifying the security being issued and the relevant valuation date. An ordinary share, preference share, growth share and EMI option do not necessarily have the same value. The analysis should reflect the company’s latest funding round, cap table, shareholder rights, restrictions on transfers, liquidation preferences, expected exit route and any commercial information available to the board. For an EMI option, companies usually seek an agreed valuation from HMRC before granting options, separating the unrestricted market value from the actual market value after restrictions are taken into account. Explore related share scheme resources for further reading on scheme design and administration.
A private company valuation normally combines several methods rather than relying on one headline number. A recent arm’s-length investment round is useful evidence, but the price paid by an investor may reflect preferred rights that employees do not receive. A market approach compares the business with similar companies, while an income approach applies a value to forecast cash flows. Early-stage businesses often require a probability-weighted assessment of future outcomes, supported by realistic revenue, funding and exit assumptions. Growth shares are usually designed with a hurdle, so the valuation focuses on the value created above that threshold rather than the company’s entire current value.
The board should approve the valuation assumptions, retain evidence supporting the methodology and record the decision in board minutes. The company then needs to check the option agreement, articles of association, shareholder agreement, employment terms and Companies House records. Current practice places greater emphasis on keeping valuations aligned with later funding rounds, documenting changes in business performance and modelling dilution before grants are made. A spreadsheet showing fully diluted ownership, option pools and exit proceeds gives employees a clearer explanation of what their award represents. Harper James can also support ongoing share plan administration, including option records, approvals and updates after fundraising or restructuring.
Common errors include valuing ordinary shares by copying the latest preference share price, ignoring transfer restrictions, granting options before the valuation is agreed, and failing to refresh the analysis after a material funding round or acquisition offer. The company should also explain vesting, leaver treatment, exercise periods, tax treatment and dilution in plain English. A valuation is not a one-off formality. It is part of the governance record that connects the scheme terms, the cap table and the company’s commercial expectations.