Harper James advises businesses on trade mark disputes under the laws of England and Wales, including infringement claims, passing off actions and UK Intellectual Property Office (UKIPO) opposition proceedings. Effective evidence establishes ownership, the parties’ trading activities, the similarity between the marks and the commercial effect of the alleged conduct.
Collect the trade mark registration certificate, application details, renewal records and any documents showing assignments or licences. For an unregistered mark, assemble dated evidence of use, such as invoices, advertising, packaging, website pages, customer communications and trade press coverage. Build a chronology showing when the mark was created, first used, registered and promoted, and when the other party began using its sign. Records of searches, warnings, settlement discussions and previous agreements also provide relevant context.
Preserve examples of the disputed use in their original form. This includes product packaging, websites, social media posts, domain names, online marketplace listings, email campaigns, signage and invoices. Record the URL, date and time, account or seller name, product description and price. Take screenshots together with the surrounding page and retain downloaded documents, source emails and original files. Do not alter the material after collection. A structured evidence log should identify who collected each item and where the original is stored.
Evidence should address the legal issue in dispute. For a registered trade mark infringement claim under the Trade Marks Act 1994, relevant material includes the similarity of the marks, the similarity of the goods or services and the way the signs are used. Customer emails, mistaken enquiries, misdirected orders, complaints, search data and sales records support an argument that the use has caused confusion or diverted business. In a passing off claim, evidence generally focuses on goodwill, misrepresentation and damage, so turnover, customer reach, advertising expenditure and examples of lost or disrupted business are important.
Keep relevant documents, messages and electronic records, including material that does not support the claim. Avoid contacting customers or publishing allegations before the evidence strategy is agreed, since those steps can create additional legal and reputational issues. Witnesses should prepare factual statements based on their own knowledge, while independent market or survey evidence requires careful design and records of the methodology. Arrange the evidence by issue and date, then map each item to the proposed UKIPO pleading, letter before action or court statement. This allows the legal team to assess the strength of the case, the likely response and the cost of each available remedy.